October 27, 2012

Immigration Influx Divides Heavener

Print More
Tienda Mexicana is one of numerous Hispanic-owned businesses that now occupy Heavener’s once dying downtown district.

Ron Jackson/Oklahoma Watch

Tienda Mexicana is one of numerous Hispanic-owned businesses that now occupy Heavener’s once dying downtown district.

HEAVENER—Atop Poteau Mountain, cloaked by white oak, black locust and other towering trees, sits the mysterious runestone. Ever since its discovery in 1874, experts have passionately debated whether the runic carvings on the stone were actually created by Viking explorers.

Today, a new dispute grips this southeastern Oklahoma community of 3,414 residents. Only this debate strays far from the intellectual trenches of academia, and is laced with a mixture of warmth, frustration, compassion and anger.

At its center are an estimated 1,410 Hispanic residents who account for 41% of Heavener’s total population, according to the 2010 Census. Based on an analysis by Oklahoma Watch, Heavener now has the third-highest concentration of Hispanic people in Oklahoma cities with 1,000 or more residents. Only Guymon and Watonga rank higher, with 52% and 47%, respectively.

A 10-year, immigration-fueled surge has only added to the tensions. Since 2000, Heavener’s Hispanic community has nearly doubled, jumping from 22%, or 721 people, to the present 41%. Some locals dispute the accuracy of the official numbers, arguing that the presence of uncounted illegal immigrants makes the true figure even higher.

In contrast to other Oklahoma communities where immigrants appear to be assimilating more smoothly, Heavener has been roiled by the rapid influx of newcomers. Neighbors argue openly, some locals say they’re ready to leave town, and two City of Heavener police officers resigned from the force in a dispute over immigration issues.

“I’m 100 percent against illegal immigration,” said Shawn Covert, a former part-time police officer who left the force last year. “I’m 100 percent for deportation—the wife, the kids, everybody. When they crossed the border illegally, they committed a felony and they should be punished as such.

“What bothers me the most is they have come in here and now they’re trying to de-Americanize us. I realize there are those who will call me a racist, but to me illegal immigration is not a race issue. It’s a legal issue.”

Perspective

Not everyone in Heavener shares Covert’s perspective.

“Look, they are hard-working, industrious people who are just trying to raise their families,” said Bruce Crickett, who moved to Heavener 27 years ago from California. “They rent. They buy groceries. They fix up houses. As far as I’m concerned, if it wasn’t for the Hispanics, this town would have dried up and blown away.”

Throughout Heavener’s old downtown district are signs of a new beginning. Mexican immigrants have moved businesses into four buildings on one street alone. One building—a former bar—is even being converted into a Catholic Church.

Until recently, time forgot Heavener’s aged downtown as most businesses moved less than a mile south on State Highway 128. The story is all too familiar in rural communities across Oklahoma. But in Heavener, the new arrivals have given the story a fresh twist.

“Some of the old-timers here want things to be like they were 40, 50 years ago when the downtown was thriving with businesses,” said Mike Kennerson, Heavener’s city manager since 2000. “Well, they’re not. Times have changed. So they blame the Hispanics. In fact, in some quarters, the Hispanics are blamed for all our ills. But the fact is they are making positive contributions to Heavener.

“Just look down the street.”

Oklahoma Foods

Heavener’s fate changed in 1988 when local organizers successfully recruited Oklahoma Foods. The company opened a chicken hatchery that year, bringing greatly needed jobs to an economically starved Le Flore County. In 1995, the company added a massive processing facility.

Today, Heavener is home to a plant where workers kill and de-bone chickens, as well as a neighboring feed mill and hatchery where the birds are carefully monitored from birth. Based on a 2009 report—the most recent data available to city officials—the company employs 985 workers with a payroll of $26 million.

Oklahoma Foods is by far Heavener’s largest employer, and without question, the principal magnet for Mexican immigrants.

“I remember back when we first heard news that the plant was coming to town,” recalled Martie Wisdom, a 1968 Heavener High School graduate who manages a downtown flower shop. “Everyone was so excited. Everyone was going to work there, and many did. Then a lot of them found it was hard work. So what did they do? They quit.

“Suddenly, there were these jobs and no one interested in filling them. Then the Hispanics came.”

Tabitha Silva, a lifelong Heavener resident, views the arrival of the Mexican immigrants as the ruination of her hometown. Silva is so disturbed by the large influx of Mexican residents that she is preparing to sell her house—a dwelling located in the middle of what many locals dub “Little Mexico.”

“I knew things were bad when my son (Nicholas, 5) came home from school his first day of pre-K,” said Silva, 33. “He said, ‘Mommy, no one in my class speaks English.’ Not only are they coming here illegally and taking our jobs and milking our system, but they’re not even trying to assimilate. We have kids going all the way through school who aren’t even trying to learn to speak English.

“We basically live in Mexico now. A lot of them have these bright pink and purple houses. I feel like I live in a cartoon.”

Silva, ironically, married a Brazilian immigrant 13 years ago. She said her husband, Neto Silva, first entered the United States with a student visa. Today he is an American citizen serving a 90-day tour in Afghanistan with the Air National Guard. He became a legal citizen in 2008, nine years after the couple’s wedding day.

“Yes, I’m married to an immigrant,” Tabitha Silva said. “But he did it the legal way. Even after we got married, we had to fill out an extensive amount of paperwork at a great financial expense.”

Silva seethes at the thought of others taking short-cuts. She isn’t alone.

Appeasement

Covert said he sees signs of a “cover-up.”

The former police officer said he resigned from his part-time post on July 1, 2011, when a superior told him he was required to give arrestees 30 minutes to post bail before transporting them to the Le Flore County jail 13 miles away in Poteau. Federal immigration officials are commonly notified by a county jailer if an individual can’t legally prove his or her residency after a reasonable search.

Covert interpreted this directive as “an appeasement” to illegal immigrants and an obstruction of his sworn duty as an officer of the law.

City Manager Kennerson contends Covert went out of his way to harass Hispanic residents.

“Look, if someone gets into trouble and they are proven illegal, then we let the law take its course,” Kennerson said. “Here’s the problem: We do not have federal immigration training, and therefore it is not up to our police officers—Shawn Covert or anyone else—to determine who is or isn’t a legal resident.

“What happened was ICE (U.S. Immigration and Customs Enforcement) was being called every five minutes to come and pick up someone we had arrested, and on a couple occasions, those individuals were proven to be legal citizens. Frankly, I’m surprised no one ever slapped us with a civil rights lawsuit.”

Covert points to House Bill 1804 as his legal authority. Specifically, he cites Section 10, Subsection C:

No local government, whether acting through its governing body or by an initiative, referendum, or any other process, shall enact any ordinance or policy that limits or prohibits a law enforcement officer, local official, or local government employee from communicating or cooperating with federal officials with regard to the immigration status of any person within this state.

“The reason the illegal immigration problem has increased so dramatically in Oklahoma is because of the lack of enforcement of House Bill 1804,” Covert said. “City governments like Heavener have created policies that create and offer sanctuary to illegal aliens.”

Police Chief Ty Armstrong defends the actions of his officers, saying his department does not promote policies—verbal or otherwise—that create a sanctuary for illegal immigrants.

“That’s the furthest thing from the truth,” Armstrong said. “The fact is we receive no support from the state or federal governments on how to deal with illegal immigrants, and we’re certainly not trained in that area. I do find it ironic that we’re being accused of being soft on illegal immigrants when, in the past, we’ve been accused by some in the Hispanic community of profiling Hispanics.”

Armstrong points to an incident a couple years ago as an example.

“I was asked to come to the school to speak with one Hispanic family who had a complaint,” Armstrong recalled. “When I arrived, I was greeted by 200 people. We moved the meeting into the gym, I grabbed a couple interpreters, and we talked. I feel like things have been fairly harmonious since then.”

As for Covert, Armstrong shrugs him off as an “outspoken man” whose views “border on the simple dislike of Mexicans.”

Tranquility seems to emanate across the valley that encompasses Heavener’s city limits. The land—once part of the Choctaw Nation—is plush with greenery, bordered by the scenic Winding Stair Mountains to the south and Poteau Mountain to the north.

The land is filled with an abundance of natural resources. The logging industry has long served as a staple of the local economy, as well as the dozens of rock quarries that still checker the countryside. They, too, have become magnets for Mexican immigrants.

Heavener also has shared a long and storied history with the Kansas City Southern Railway Company, which now uses a local depot as one of its main fueling stops.

Manuel and Minerva Martinez

Heavener, in short, is the portrait of prosperity to Mexican immigrants like Manuel and Minerva Martinez. They journeyed to the United States in 1997 from the far southern Mexican state of Oaxaca, first living in Texas before hearing of opportunities in Heavener.

“Some people we knew told us of the [processing] plant,” said Manuel, whose words were interpreted by his 14-year-old son, Luis. “They told us there was work here, and so we came. I found it very tranquil.”

Violence back home in Mexico—turf wars between rival cartels—played a role in driving the family north, Manuel said. Today, he works at a local rock quarry driving a forklift, and as he notes, “paying taxes.”

Minerva, meanwhile, runs a little taqueria and store in Heavener’s old downtown district. Their four children—Luis, 14; Edward, 11; Klen, 10; and Benji, 7—attend public school and can often be seen visiting the local library down the street from the family’s business.

The couple emphasizes education. Minerva said she was forced to leave school after the eighth grade, while Manuel dropped out after the fifth grade to go to work.

“In Mexico,” Minerva explained, “you have to pay to go to school. Only the wealthy could afford to send their kids to school. If you couldn’t come up with the money, you didn’t go.

“My dream is for my children to go to college.”

Dreams

Cesar De la Rosa understands dreams.

De la Rosa arrived in Heavener in 2001, having risked his life by crossing the border illegally in a desert region. He walked for three straight days and nights across the desert before reaching safety.

Since then, De la Rosa has become a respected member of the community. For the past two years he has served the Heavener High School soccer team as an assistant coach. He has even been called upon by his Methodist Church to deliver a sermon from time to time.

In 2005, De la Rosa spearheaded the creation of a summer soccer league. Thirty children played the first year. This summer the league catered to 68 children and five teams.

“We started the program as a way to bring the Mexican children and American children together,” said De la Rosa, 42. “We noticed they were having problems getting along. But now we see almost no problems at all. Everyone seems to get along really well.

“Soccer brought them together.”

De la Rosa, who works at the hatchery, hopes to help build a new soccer complex on city-owned land behind the Oklahoma Foods processing plant. Only he may not be around to see the complex become a reality.

In May 2011, De la Rosa was arrested by local police after he failed to produce a valid driver’s license. A deportation hearing has been scheduled for him in February.

“I was stopped because the light on my tag was out,” De la Rosa said. “The police were hunting Mexicans that night. They succeeded in arresting about five of us.”

John Wilson of Heavener said he was one of the arresting officers that night. He said he never patrolled specifically in search of illegal immigrants.

“I knew Cesar was illegal when I arrested him,” said Wilson, 64. “We had problems with him before.”

Like Covert, Wilson also resigned his part-time post last July over the immigration issue. Prior to his resignation, he had served the department for 30 years.

“What would Heavener look like if all the illegals were deported? Well, it would probably be a ghost town. And that would be fine with me,” Wilson said. “They are destroying this community.”

De la Rosa doesn’t understand the anger. Nor does it matter to him these days.

“Will I be deported?” De la Rosa asked sadly. “Probably. I hope not, but if they send me back to Mexico, my dream—my passion—is to build those soccer fields for this town and for my kids. That would make me happy.”

Oklahoma Watch staff reporter Ron J. Jackson, Jr. is an award-winning journalist and author whose professional writing career spans 26 years. He spent 14 years with The Oklahoman, investigating stories statewide on topics such Mexican drug cartels, illegal immigration and unsolved homicides.

Ron Jackson Jr. of Oklahoma Watch joined OETA host Dick Pryor and Giovanni Perry of the League of United Latin American Citizens for a discussion of Oklahoma’s Hispanic population and its effect on the election.”

  • Josh

    You see our city manager Mike Kennerson talk about how he likes the immigrants here, who is he to say he don’t even live in this city, he lives in poteau, but tries to run Heavener and don’t do it well. Write a story about that, he is running this city down.

  • angela

    Ok let me say this on the published article on heavener I think all the people who wanna talk trash about Mexicans taken their jobs and running people off and kids going to the same school as their kids and everyone talking about them being illegal. Well y’all idiots need to grow up and not all of them come here illegal. Stupid, and if they do who cares people are never satisfied. First it was Indians, then the blacks. And now the Mexicans. How I feel, y’all need to keep your mouths shut about other people and worry about your own

  • Luis Hernandez

    If Latinos were deported, the racists left behind would starve just like the Latinos were doing before finding heavener. The only difference is Latinos look for work. Idiot racists would just starve to death

  • I worked at OK Feed Mill for 12 years, and over those 12 years I have seen crime rise in Heavener. Drugs being sold off the back docks of the poultry plant, homes being burglarized and illegals driving drunk without licenses and causing wrecks when doing so, and child molestations by illegals. I drive through Heavener and see the trashy way they live, never seen any of these people fix up a place to live, but then Heavener really isn’t a classy place of lifestyle anyway. After all they don’t offer a classy style of work. I was leaving work one morning, even seen a group of the illegals had cut a fence line outside of the city limits about 5:30 am; they were loading cows onto a enclosed trailer. I reported what I had seen but they were gone before anybody responded to the issue. OK Farms could care less about how illegal the people are as long as they can get work out of them. I was at a farm of Ok’s one time, the grower had 5 illegals working for him and only papers he paid for on 2 of them. He said he just hides 3 of them when anyone wants to check on them. There are many hidden illegals because of the chicken industry and the only folks that won’t complain of them being here are those who are benefiting from their labor. The same folks are not held responsible for the crimes they commit, and they should be. Not all the illegals in the area are working just because these companies claim they are. For each household you might have 2 workers out of 10 living in the house and census is far off of what reality is. Census is only getting numbers that are written down, which is a forged count. I agree with the officers that quit their jobs; they are there to uphold the law, and the illegals have broken the law and many other laws and law enforcement turns their heads to it. Our jails are full of criminals that broke laws less then these illegals have. We need a new Government that will uphold our laws on this this issue. Heavner is not a place I ever advise anyone to live.

    • alkimizta

      You crazy! So you see a brown person and you automatically assumed they are “illegal aliens!” Seeing without knowing is blind judgement! Bias equals stupidity!

  • jimmy amos

    Need to investegate why everyones water bills are a 100.00 a month i think thats more important to worry about there ripping us off need a whole new city employee i think

  • Carlos

    Well well now i know how some people feel. if you seen me before you probably know who i am. I have lived in this town cense 1982 and i have seen a lot of changes. But one thing has not change and that is the ignorance of some people. When i moved here i was legal. i came here legally, but people was calling me Mexican. now remember that i came here legally, but people was still calling me wetback. They would say hey you wetback why dont you go back to mexico where you belong. Now as a little kid back then and the only Latino in the school it was very hard for me to deal with. By the way im not Mexican but because i speak Spanish people assume that im Mexican. Thats where the ignorance part comes in.

  • Michael

    Heavener is going down the toilet, but it isn’t the fault of the immigrants. LeFlore county is dysfunctional, and has been for years. No money, no jobs, and everything is ran by a bunch of backwater rednecks who are only looking out for themselves. Try and name the last politician that ever did right by LeFlore county and wasn’t a corrupt thief.

    To those complaining about a lack of assimilation – it doesn’t happen overnight. After a couple more generations, you’ll begin to see it. That said, do you really expect immigrants to assimilate when they get treated like dirt by their neighbors? You’re only breeding more ill-will by doing this. The Mexican population of Heavener isn’t going away. You’re better off getting to know them, and keeping an open dialogue with their community.

  • Lee

    I don’t think you can blame OK Foods. I lived in Heavener 24 years and worked for the KCS. It was a nice place to raise our family and pretty much drug free until after they got grown and left. OK built the plants there because there was a lot of people unemployed and on public assistance and they needed labor. After they built the plant you could drive by the county building on commodity days and there would be a long line of people drawing commodities and I knew some of them were able to work while the plant was having to hire illegals. The democratic party is promoting more of this and full time unemployment benefits for our citizens for the promise of their vote.