November 13, 2014

State Business Tax Breaks More Than Double, to $760 Million

Print More
Wind turbines near Hunter in Garfield County spin on Thursday. Tax incentives offered to wind-power companies have drawn criticism.

Bonnie Vculek/Enid News & Eagle

Wind turbines near Hunter in Garfield County spin on Thursday. Tax incentives offered to wind-power companies have drawn criticism.


Key industry tax breaks in Oklahoma have more than doubled over the past four years and are now costing the state well over half a billion dollars a year, state records show.

The two dozen business tax breaks combined grew from $356 million in 2010 to $760 million in 2014. The 2014 figure is equivalent to just over 10 percent of the state’s $7.2 billion budget, and more than the state spends every year on prisons and public safety.

An Oklahoma Watch analysis of data obtained from the Oklahoma Tax Commission, Oklahoma Insurance Department and Senate Finance Committee shows that the growth has been fueled by incentives provided to oil, gas and wind-power producers.

Together, the energy industry tax breaks reduced state revenue collections by $486 million in 2014. The other tax breaks related to areas such as job creation, the film industry and historic building rehabilitation.

Some lawmakers and advocacy groups say the lost revenue is harmful to the state, restricting its ability to invest in core services such as education and health care or to offer broad-based cuts in income or sales taxes.

State Sen. Mike Mazzei, R-Tulsa

Oklahoma Senate

State Sen. Mike Mazzei, R-Tulsa

“It’s the largest corporate welfare giveaway in the history of Oklahoma,” said Senate Finance Committee Chairman Mike Mazzei, R-Tulsa. “It’s going to crowd out our ability to do other levels of tax reform, other levels of lower taxes for people, small businesses and other industries that aren’t in oil and gas.”

Supporters of the subsidies insist that they help pay for themselves by generating economic growth and creating jobs. Energy industry leaders say without oil and gas production tax breaks, they would make new drilling methods less cost-effective and stifle exploration.

“My neighbors, my families, my friends are employed by those people,” said Rep. David Dank, R-Oklahoma City. “We’re doing the geology and the engineering for wells that are being drilled in Ohio and West Virginia and Pennsylvania. I want that to continue.”

State Rep. David Dank, R-Oklahoma City

Oklahoma House

State Rep. David Dank, R-Oklahoma City

Leaders in both parties have voiced concern about the growth in tax breaks and have taken steps to pare them back. Since 2010, the legislature has repealed, capped or attached “sunset” dates to several dozen business tax breaks.

According to a newly released report by the Oklahoma Tax Commission, the number of all exclusions, exemptions, deductions, credits and other tax breaks that it tracks declined from 480 in 2010 to 455 in fiscal year 2014.

But the legislature has rejected efforts to rein in others, even as the total amount of business tax breaks has soared, tightening the squeeze on state revenue collections.

“We’ve done some positive things that have never been done before … in terms of cleaning up some special-interest tax breaks,” Mazzei said. “But we’ve started some new ones that have greatly increased taxpayer-subsidized support for some special interests.”

The Tax Commission’s latest tally of “tax expenditures” adds up to billions of dollars of lost revenue every year if every kind of tax preference is considered.

Many of the biggest breaks benefit very broad constituencies and enjoy widespread popular support. An example is the sales tax exemption for prescription drugs, which reduced state revenue by $136 million in 2014.

Mazzei estimated that tax reforms already enacted by the legislature were boosting annual revenue collections by at least $100 million. They include the phasing-out of three controversial tax credit programs for venture capital investments.

Tax breaks for energy companies have soared since 2010. In this photo, despite freezing temperatures Thursday, members of the Tomcat Drilling Rig 5 crew continued their quest for oil next to U.S. 81 north of Enid.

Bonnie Vculek / Enid News & Eagle

Tax breaks for energy companies have soared since 2010. In this photo, despite freezing temperatures Thursday, members of the Tomcat Drilling Rig 5 crew continued their quest for oil next to U.S. 81 north of Enid.

At the top of Mazzei’s setback list, however, is this year’s expansion of gross production tax preferences for oil and gas production, he said. In response to intense energy industry lobbying, the legislature replaced a temporary tax break for horizontally drilled wells with a permanent tax break for all wells during their first three years of production.

Even before the change, the horizontal well tax break had soared in cost from $83 million in 2010 to $363 million in fiscal year 2014. (The 2014 figure includes $94 million in rebates paid out during 2014 for production during two earlier years when the tax break was suspended.)

It appears unlikely that the legislature would consider scaling back the gross production tax at this point. The oil and gas industry has strong support from lawmakers who say it has become the backbone of the Oklahoma economy, generating jobs and revenue that might be endangered if the tax breaks were curtailed.

Rep. Dank has been a key figure in the crusade to get rid of certain tax breaks. But he said he is a firm supporter of the gross production tax incentives because of the oil industry’s contributions to the state.

“What’s more important to me than the gross production tax is the high-paying jobs that are created in the Devon Tower, by Continental, by Sandridge, by Sampson, by Chesapeake,” Dank said.

Wind turbines in Garfield County..

Bonnie Vculek / Enid News & Eagle

Wind turbines in Garfield County..

Wind Power Credit

If the gross production tax breaks appear secure for now, another energy industry tax subsidy, the wind power credit, is in the crosshairs of reformers who say its rapid growth is imperiling state revenue collections without a big economic payoff.

In 2003, the state began providing an income tax credit to companies that built wind-powered electricity generating plants. A year later, it added wind-power facilities to the list of manufacturers eligible to receive five-year property tax exemptions. Although property tax collections go to county governments and schools, the state reimburses them for the manufacturing exemptions.

The combined cost of the wind-power income tax credits and property tax exemptions ballooned from $7 million in 2010 to $50 million in 2014, according to the Senate Finance Committee.

Supporters sold the legislature on the idea that the tax breaks were needed to help jump-start an environmentally friendly energy source that offered potential long-term payoffs to the state. Critics contend the industry generates few long-term jobs once the wind farms are up and running.

The Senate Finance Committee conducted an interim legislative study of the wind power tax breaks this fall. Mazzei said he intended to propose changes during the 2015 legislative session.

Incentives for Jobs

Another big-ticket incentive that might receive scrutiny is the Quality Jobs Program. Created in 1993, it provides direct payments to manufacturers who create new jobs by building new facilities in Oklahoma or expanding existing ones.

It, too, has grown rapidly in recent years. Direct payouts to manufacturers were $82 million in 2014 compared to $54 million in 2010.

Oklahoma’s Quality Jobs program has been touted by Dank and others as one of the best programs of its kind nationwide. But even some supporters contend it might have become too generous.

Under a 2008 amendment, for example, the partnership that owns Oklahoma City’s Thunder basketball team now qualifies for the Quality Jobs Program. Professional Basketball Club LLC received $4 million in payouts during the 2014 fiscal year.

(The Thunder’s owners include oilman George Kaiser of Tulsa. The George Kaiser Family Foundation is one of Oklahoma Watch’s principal funders.)

Even if Quality Jobs is considered a national model, companies sometimes eliminate jobs for which they have been receiving subsidies. Under the program’s terms, the state pays the companies for up to ten years. If the firms eliminate the jobs in a downsizing, the payments stop. In most cases, no payback is required.

Larkin Warner, a retired Oklahoma State University economics professor who served for years on the state’s Incentive Review Committee, said he thinks the legislature should make sure the program is kept within reasonable limits.

Yet he cautioned that Oklahoma must remain competitive with other states in providing economic growth incentives.

“We have to meet or beat the competition,” Warner said. “We could thumb our nose and say, ‘Well, we’re not going to stoop that low.’ And then along comes another state and just takes business away from us.”

No State Comparisons

Although some national organizations track state tax breaks, Oklahoma Watch could find no comprehensive data to assess how Oklahoma’s complete package of business incentives compares with that of other states.

“The trouble is, there are no standardized rules,” said Greg LeRoy, executive director of Good Jobs First, a nonprofit research group in Washington, D.C., that has been publishing state tax-break data for four years.

LeRoy said the Governmental Accounting Standards Board (GASB) recently drafted its first proposed rules for defining business incentives. But until standardized rules are adopted, no comprehensive comparative data is available, he said.

“We can’t (provide it). The data doesn’t exist in a uniform way because of GASB’s negligence. The states have resisted, too,” LeRoy said. “You get into a lot of gnarly, definitional gray areas.”

Despite the limited success of past tax reform initiatives, Mazzei said he intends to continue pushing for lower tax rates across the board and few or no special-interest tax breaks.

“The lesson we need to learn is that when we stay in the habit of picking winners and losers and helping one special-interest group over another, we fail to make progress toward what is best for everyone,” Mazzei said.

Dank said he, too, would keep pushing for more reforms.

“I think we’re winning converts,” Dank said. “I think we’re making progress.”

Reach reporter Warren Vieth at wvieth@oklahomawatch.org.


Sign up for a weekly newsletter from Oklahoma Watch


Donate Today

Please consider donating to Oklahoma Watch in support of nonpartisan, in-depth, investigative journalism on some of the most important, challenging public-policy issues facing our state today.

  • Debbie

    The small-government-is-good-government crowd continues to hold a pillow over the face of state government. The body is barely thrashing around, still fighting suffocation, but it’s clear that the attack won’t end until the gasps for oxygen —for education funding, road and bridge repair, mental health services (and so on…) — finally cease and the body has no fight left in it. Winning!

  • RAY WALL

    Business Tax Breaks create future revenue to be paid to the State to support non-revenue producing programs that protect, serve, educate, help etc. the citizens of Oklahoma. While the concept of Business Tax Breaks is valid and necessary, the availability of verifiable facts to measure the ROI of a specific Business Tax Break is not made available for public evaluation.
    The accurate and verifiable ROI for a specific Business Tax Break should be available to the voters. Are the elected Representatives and Senators granting Tax Breaks to those who are consistently producing the highest ROI?

  • Josh

    I would like to point out that oil and gas have been funded by tax credits for a long, long time. Wind has only had tax credits applied by the state since 2003. The oil and gas industries are possibly going to receive permanent tax credits. Between 2014 and 2015 fiscal years, the oil and gas credits will cost the state over $1Billion. That is just two of the tens of years the oil and gas industry have been subsidized, versus the little over ten years the wind business has been subsidized. Saying that wind is overly subsidized, when it is a burgeoning industry is ignoring the history of the state: http://oklahomawatch.org/2014/05/22/oil-and-gas-tax-bill-clears-house-senate/

  • Dennis

    The wind industry creates very few jobs for the cost to the state. Why should Oklahoma fit the bill by providing tax breaks to wind energy companies who are using a Oklahoma resource (wind) and making electric to send to other states and Oklahomans don’t receive anything from it. No electric, very few jobs, and only a heavy tax burden to the state. At least oil and gas employee thousands of Oklahomans. Wind farms shouldn’t receive tax credits companies that produce wind products and create jobs in Oklahoma should.