December 6, 2014

Mothers Blames Doctors, Pain Clinics for Daughter’s Death

Print More

TX - Addicted Oklahoma bug closerA back injury six years ago led Carie Marie Simmons into a life of prescription drugs, addiction and, eventually, an early death, her mother says.

But Helen Broadbooks, 63, of Lexington, also blames the doctors and pain clinics that treated her daughter, who overdosed and died May 13, 2013, on a combination of hydrocodone, morphine, oxycodone, alprazolam (Xanax), carisoprodol (a muscle relaxer) and meprobamate (a tranquilizer). She was 27.

Carrie Marie Simmons died of a drug overdose in 2013. She is shown here with her husband Drew Dean Simmons.

Facebook Photo

Carrie Marie Simmons died of a drug overdose in 2013. She is shown here with her husband Drew Dean Simmons.

Broadbooks said her daughter saw Dr. William Valuck for about two years, first at Vista Medical Center and later at Advanced Care Clinic, where Valuck practiced before authorities arrested him in December 2013 for his role in the overdose deaths of several of his patients. Valuck, 72, pleaded guilty in August in Oklahoma County District Court to eight counts of second-degree murder and was given an eight-year prison sentence.

“They get them hooked on (prescription drugs) and then they got somebody that’s gonna come back every month and pay the money,” Broadbooks said.

Broadbooks said Simmons’ husband found her dead in their Lexington home.

“She had gotten up and was in the living room. She’d had a really bad toothache that morning, and I think she took one thing, then took another, then another,” she said. “She died of ‘mixed drug toxicity.’ It was that mixture of things — medications that were prescribed to her — that killed her.”

Simmons was born in Liberal, Kan., and moved to Oklahoma with her family in May 1992.

She grew up in the Noble area and attended Noble High School as well as Robinson Street Baptist School in Norman.

Simmons’ obituary said she had a lifelong love of singing and dancing, was a loyal friend and confidant and that her passing had “left a giant hole in the hearts of all those that knew and loved her.”


Sign up for a weekly newsletter from Oklahoma Watch


Donate Today



Please consider donating to Oklahoma Watch in support of nonpartisan, in-depth, investigative journalism on some of the most important, challenging public-policy issues facing our state today.

  • Ms. Bevie Luningham

    Im so very sorry for this young womans death. No mother should have to experience the pain and sheer suffering of laying a child to rest. However, I feel too many times Doctors are unfairly blamed for deaths such as this. There is only one person to blame. The young lady herself who kept taking her medication to alleviate pain for a toothache. She didnt receive her pain managment meds for such a purpose. Overdoses and toxicity deaths are due to not taking medication as perscribed.