March 13, 2016

Charter School Growth Stirs New Ambitions, Worries

Print More
Real estate developer Grant Humphreys wants to stop operating Carlton Landing Academy, located on the shores of Lake Eufaula, as a private school and re-open it as a public charter school.

Leilani Ott

Real estate developer Grant Humphreys wants to stop operating Carlton Landing Academy, located on the shores of Lake Eufaula, as a private school and re-open it as a public charter school.

A proposed charter school in a lakeside resort community would mark the state’s first expansion of public charters into rural areas under a new law allowing for their presence statewide, school officials say.

The proposal to bring a public charter school to the tiny town of Carlton Landing on Lake Eufaula comes amid a climate of rapid expansion in the charter school sector.

In February, proposals surfaced to add charter school sites within Oklahoma City Public Schools, the state’s largest school district. Tulsa is sponsoring three new charter schools, all of which have a college prep focus.

As of Oct. 1, charter schools enrolled 19,893 students in the state, according to the Oklahoma Department of Education. About half the students are in online charter schools.

The surge in plans for charter schools, which are publicly funded schools allowed to operate under fewer requirements than district schools, is being driven by several factors. For non-urban areas, it is a change in state law in 2015 that for the first time permits charter schools sponsored by school districts to open in areas outside of Oklahoma City and Tulsa.

The expansion sought in Oklahoma City is due in large part to the strong enrollment growth in some of the city’s highest-profile charter schools: Santa Fe South Schools, the city’s largest charter school system; John Rex Charter Elementary downtown, and KIPP Reach College Preparatory in the northeast area.

Chris Brewster, superintendent of Santa Fe South, said the proposal is about giving options to parents.

“High quality options can be traditional public schools, magnet schools, charter schools. The goal is to be part of the solution … to make sure every student in Oklahoma City has a great place to attend,” he said.

However, the trend worries district school leaders and parent and teacher groups, who say charter school growth will erode state and local financial support of district schools, which must teach the most impoverished and challenging students.

Tensions Over School

Real estate developer Grant Humphreys has a deep motivation for pursuing a charter school for Carlton Landing, the town he founded.

Humphreys moved to Carlton Landing five years ago with his wife and five children. All of his children attend the school. He owns the homebuilding company responsible for the steady construction of upscale homes in Carlton Landing. His vision for the picturesque community includes numerous amenities, with a thriving school as a cornerstone.

Humphreys is the son of former Oklahoma City Mayor Kirk Humphreys, who led the MAPS for Kids initiative during his tenure and serves on the board of the John Rex Charter Elementary, the final MAPS for Kids project. Kirk Humphreys also owns a home in Carlton Landing.

The location of the proposed charter now operates as Carlton Landing Academy, a private school, and has also been a magnet school for the Canadian Public Schools district. It has 20 students.

While state law prohibits a private school from contracting with a charter school, the applicant in this case is a new nonprofit. The private school plans to close in June, and the new charter would open in August.

In its application, Carlton Landing Academy proposes a unique school calendar based on six, six-week sessions and a nature-centric curriculum that includes an “edible schoolyard,” teaching gardening and cooking along with core subjects like English and math.

Grant Humphreys said the charter is poised to be a model for educational excellence in rural Oklahoma.

“We think it will bring more people to this part of the state as full-time residents,” Humphreys said. “But we also think it’s something that could attract people into Carlton Landing Academy from surrounding districts.”

But Humphreys’ proposal doesn’t sit well with everyone in this scenic patch of the state.

Echoing concerns of other superintendents, Canadian Superintendent Rodney Karch said he worries that the Carlton Landing charter would siphon off students from his district – and the public funding that comes with them.

“If they eventually pull 25 or 30 of our kids to come out there, they do all right, but we get hurt,” said Karch, whose district is a 10-mile drive west of Carlton Landing.

Karch is struggling to cope with state-mandated budget cuts that reduced allocations to schools. After the state declared a second revenue failure March 3, Canadian shortened its current school year by nine days to save money.

Losing just 30 students to the new charter could prove devastating, Karch said.

Carlton Landing Academy projects an enrollment of 50 students its first year, growing to 150 in five years. While the school is convenient for Carlton Landing residents, enrollment will be open to any student in its attendance area.

On March 1, the Canadian Public Schools board held a lengthy discussion on whether to sponsor the charter school. It was approved 4-1 over Karch’s objections.

Board President Orda Selph said they worried if they rejected the proposal, the charter would appeal and the state Board of Education would sponsor it anyway.

“I felt like they were going to get their school no matter what. And if we had some input, maybe it would be better on us,” he said.

The next step is for the school board to consider a contract with the charter, which could happen at its April meeting.

“Any way you figure it, it’s going to hurt us,” Karch said. “But the laws are what they are.”

Humphreys holds a different view.

“In rural Oklahoma, I think what people want is, they want options,” he said.

Carlton Landing, where the new charter school would be located, is an affluent community on the shores of Lake Eufaula. The prices of some available homes cost hundreds of thousands of dollars.

Leilani Ott

Carlton Landing, where the new charter school would be located, is an affluent community on the shores of Lake Eufaula. The prices of some available homes cost hundreds of thousands of dollars.

Growth in Charters

Seven new charter schools have opened in Oklahoma since 2014, bringing the state total to 29 excluding virtual schools, according to the state Education Department.

They are College Bound Academy, Collegiate Hall, Langston Hughes Academy for Arts and Technology and Tulsa Honor Academy, in Tulsa; and Lighthouse Academies and John W. Rex Charter Elementary in Oklahoma City.

Also in 2015, the Office of Juvenile Affairs opened a charter school called Oklahoma Youth Academy for incarcerated teens at its facilities in Tecumseh and Manitou.

In addition to new charter programs emerging, enrollment at some existing charter schools has risen sharply.

Santa Fe South schools, a charter with an elementary, middle and high school in south Oklahoma City, added more than 600 students across all grade levels from 2014 to 2015. More than 90 percent of its students are Hispanic and English language learners, and nearly all qualify for free or reduced-price lunch.

“We’ve got classrooms in old racquet ball rooms and a dance hall and a hardware store and everywhere else we can have kids,” said Brewster, the superintendent. “Facilities are our number one issue.” The school still has a waiting list.

John Rex Charter Elementary in downtown Oklahoma City grew its student population by 19 percent in the fall of 2015, its second school year in operation.

Not all charters are experiencing growth, however. Enrollment at KIPP Tulsa and KIPP Reach in Oklahoma City dipped 16.2 percent and 3.3 percent, respectively, education department data shows. Enrollment at Seeworth Academy, one of the state’s oldest charter schools, was down 7.4 percent.

Nationwide, student enrollment in public charters has grown by 62 percent over five years; 45 districts have charter-school enrollment of 20 percent or more. Thirteen percent of students in Oklahoma City Public Schools now attend a charter, according to an analysis by the National Alliance for Public Charter Schools.

Tougher Requirements

It’s unclear whether the charter growth will continue at the same pace during the next several years.

Although charter schools have become attractive alternatives in parts of urban areas, expansion in rural communities could prove more difficult because of sparser populations and the presence of many small districts. Also, when the Legislature opened the door last year for expansion beyond the largest cities, it also toughened the school application process. An application now must include a detailed start-up plan, financial plan and plans for serving students with disabilities, English language learners and academically struggling students.

Charter schools already must maintain state accreditation and be accountable to their sponsors, most of which are school districts or universities. They remain exempt from many state regulations, such as minimum teacher pay and teacher certification and tenure.

The new law also makes it easier for the state to close underperforming charters.

Nevertheless, there are signs of mounting interest.

Twice a year, the state Education Department holds a training session for anyone interested in the regulations and procedures for establishing a charter school. At the most recent one on March 1, about 30 people attended, department officials said.

Among the attendees were several representatives from charter-school groups in other states who are seeking sponsors for new schools in Oklahoma, said Bill Weldon, interim superintendent at Seminole Public Schools. He attended the session because he has heard there is an effort in his community to establish a charter school.

“It was more or less a defense mechanism,” he said of his attendance.

Weldon said his district is trying to survive potentially drastic state funding cuts to schools. He worries if a charter opens in his area, it would attract Seminole students and his enrollment would drop.

He noted that the Seminole High School building was condemned last summer, so he moved students into a temporary space and is seeking help from a bond initiative to fund a new school.

“We’re all in survival mode in public schools right now anyway, with budget cuts and trying to make the best of it,” Weldon said.

  • gafgal

    It’s clear what those with financial resources want: good schooling and good surroundings for their children. That’s what people without financial resources want too. They just don’t have the political savvy, voice or money to make themselves heard. They may find that those who have no children or whose children are no longer in school push to stop their tax contributions. Seems to me, the push to finagle tax dollars to support private-like schools will help a few and harm a lot. Those who should know better, in my opinion, are selfish.

  • Mark

    QUOTE Santa Fe South schools, a charter with an elementary, middle and high school in south Oklahoma City, added more than 600 students across all grade levels from 2014 to 2015. More than 90 percent of its students are Hispanic and English language learners, and nearly all qualify for free or reduced-price lunch. END QUOTE. This was in the above article.

  • Jesse Leyva

    I understand the concerns expressed by districts about losing students and thus revenue. I also understand that some families are attracted to charter schools in part because they have some level of dissatisfaction with their local school(s). If I were a district experiencing declining enrollment due to the presence of a charter school, I would make sure I am listening to the community, while making all possible efforts to respond to their needs and desires.
    As a former district and charter school administrator, I can empathize with board sides and I understand there are always solutions to problems for those with a growth mindset.

  • Rodney Karch, Superintendent Canadian Schools

    Public schools are what they are, open to the public. However, the push that public schools are not doing their jobs is a false narrative. We must educate all students, even those who do not want to be educated. Parents are the ones who must push students to learn; our job is to try to do our best to educate them, despite their economic or social problems. We also educate in most small schools over 20% special ed students along with the rest. This is never considered in private schools or charter schools. We are also graded for those special ed students’ performance on state testing at the same rate as regular students. It is time to realize that society itself dictates the success or failure of our schools’ success. I am tired of the criticism of our public schools by political pundits who have no clue as to what it is like to teach students who really don’t want to learn or a class with 20% special ed students. We do a pretty good job overall. We still educate most of our doctors, lawyers, teachers, and other professional people. Since we do not have money to provide funds to run our public schools, then why start more schools or provide vouchers to people who don’t send their kids to public schools? Let’s properly fund public schools before we provide funds for others.