Defying Local School Board, State Board Approves Charter School

Print More

Jennifer Palmer/Oklahoma Watch

Supporters of a charter school in Seminole showed up in blue shirts at the State Board of Education meeting Thursday.

A unanimous vote Thursday by the State Board of Education sends a message to public school boards across the state: If you won’t sponsor a charter school, we may do it instead.

The Seminole Public Schools board had twice rejected the application for the Academy of Seminole, and the state board took up the application on appeal. In a packed boardroom after several hours of discussion, the board voted to sponsor the school itself.

It’s unprecedented in Oklahoma.

In amending the Charter School Act in 2015, the legislature made several changes that paved the way for the Seminole charter. It opened up charters statewide – previously charters were restricted to the state’s urban areas – and it allowed the Board of Education to sponsor up to five charter schools per year if the applicant had been denied by the local school district.

More than 100 parents and community members attended the meeting to show support for the proposal for a charter school with a curriculum based on science, technology, engineering and math, or STEM. The school will at first offer 11th and 12th grades but plans to expand to preK through 12th within three years. It will initially share space on the Seminole State College campus.

“It’s a historic moment,” said Robert Ruiz, executive director of Choice Matters, an Oklahoma City-based organization that promotes charter schools. The message, he said, is that school boards should consider charter applications based on merit, regardless of politics.

Others in public education viewed the decision as a loss of local control.

“We’re disappointed in the state board’s vote to override a locally-elected body’s decision,” said Alicia Priest, president of the Oklahoma Education Association. “The Seminole Board of Education responded appropriately to voices in its community, but the state board ignored that decision. Creation of a charter school should be a local decision, not an usurping of local control.”

Seminole community member Marilyn Rainwater also had concerns.

“Do we have local control at our local school board, or do we not? I fear if there is a decision to overturn the unanimous decision by our school board, it’s going to send a message that … we really don’t control what’s going on.”

The Academy of Seminole is set to become the second charter school outside of Oklahoma City and Tulsa. Carlton Landing Academy, a former private school in a small community on Lake Eufaula, became the first when it opened in 2016.

Carlton Landing Academy is sponsored by Canadian Public Schools, although its board reluctantly voted to approve the school. The Canadian board president said board members felt if they rejected the proposal, the school would appeal and the state Board of Education would sponsor it anyway.

In Seminole, a town of 7,500 residents about 55 miles southeast of Oklahoma City, a rift developed over its public high school building. Twice voters have rejected bond proposals to build a new high school, and the 87-year-old historic high school building has since been declared unsafe for occupancy. Students are now being educated in a converted retail building that was most recently a call center.

Division over the first proposal in 2015, which was to build a new school on the east side of town, came to a head when dueling full-page advertisements appeared in the Seminole newspaper, The Oklahoman reported. University of Oklahoma President David Boren, a Seminole High School alumni, came out against the idea, while oilman and former Seminole Mayor Melvin Moran was a proponent.

The second proposal attempted to satisfy both sides by preserving some of the historic building while rebuilding the rest. It, too, was defeated.

In considering the Seminole proposal, state Superintendent of Public Instruction Joy Hofmeister laid blame for the bond proposals’ failure on the school board.

“It shows me the community doesn’t support the plan the school board put forth both times,” she said. “I have a problem with that.”

Paul Campbell, president and chief executive of the Seminole-based aerospace manufacturer Enviro Systems, is driving the charter effort. He formed Advance Rural Education, an Oklahoma foundation applying for 501(c)3 status to support the charter school. The Kentucky native, who was appointed to his post in 2015, said his company struggles to recruit engineers because they don’t want to send their children to Seminole schools.

The academy plans to contract with ResponsiveEd, a charter school operator based in Lewisville, Texas, to manage the Seminole academy. The school must still seek the state school board’s approval of a contract.

Lee Denney, a former legislator who co-authored the 2015 bill to amend the charter school law, is on the Academy of Seminole’s governing board.

Another businessman, Chuck Mills of Shawnee, spoke to the board in support of the charter. “This academy is not just about Seminole. It’s about the region, the state. We’ve got to look at the big picture … There’s a lot of communities that would love to see this happen. They don’t have the resources and champions to take the abuse and buck the trend.”

Currently, the state Board of Education sponsors one charter school, Oklahoma Youth Academy Charter School, which operates in the state’s incarcerated boys’ facilities in Tecumseh and Manitou.

  • evan haney, A.I.M.

    I don’t live in the seminole school district but I support ‘public education’ by way of property taxes paid in seminole county. Seminole school district has a large student enrollment and probably more than 100 parents. These more than 100 parents may be against using PUBLIC EDUCATION monies for a PRIVATE charter school. Enviro employees and children of employees may not all live in the town of seminole. The 100 private school supporters may not have even voted. In any case, the democratic ‘will of the people’ has been thwarted by a 2 man, 3 man or 4 man appeals board….though not more than the parents who voted against the transfer of public monies to private purposes.

    these smoke and mirror tactics has nothing to do with the self-determination of the parents to decide where their school will eventually be.

    • Mark Hughes

      Unfortunately public schools are failing our children and parents are looking for other alternatives to save their children’s futures and I don’t blame them.