It was not a call that Rabekah Crow expected.
The Bartlesville resident was working at her job as a Phillips 66 help-desk agent in spring 2018 when an unfamiliar number flashed across her caller ID.
“The person just said they were outside of my work and were delivering papers for me to sign,” she said. “So I thought, ‘No big deal.’”
When she came out, she was served with a lawsuit demanding payment of nearly $3,500 in medical bills from the birth of her youngest son in 2015.
The bill was from St. John Health System’s Jane Phillips Medical Center and Hospital. Crow thought it had been paid because she had filed paperwork asking for Medicaid to cover the delivery. But the hospital disagreed.
Nearly three months later, a Washington County district judge issued a default judgment in favor of the hospital. Crow failed to challenge the lawsuit in time, saying later she couldn’t afford a lawyer and was unfamiliar with the legal system.
The judge later ordered Phillips 66 to withhold as much as $470 from Crow’s twice-a-month paycheck until her debt – which had grown to $4,230 with interest and attorney fees – was paid. For more than four months Crow saw her take-home payment reduced by a quarter.
The debt took a toll on her and her three children, she said.
“I ended up taking three personal loans on my retirement, which I’m now having to pay back out of my paychecks,” she said. “It’s just been horrible.”
Crow’s experience is not an uncommon one across Oklahoma.
An Oklahoma Watch review of court records since 2016 found that dozens of hospitals across the state have filed at least 22,250 lawsuits against their former patients over unpaid medical bills.
In many of those cases, the hospitals have garnished wages to collect anywhere from a few hundred dollars to more than $10,000. The hospitals are nonprofit, for-profit and government-owned ones – some of them founded by charity or religious organizations.
These billing practices highlight a heated debate in the medical community across the country. When do hospitals have a financial responsibility to aggressively pursue debt collections? When should they be more willing to write off unpaid bills for low-income patients who struggle just to get by?
Hospital officials say they already offer millions of dollars in charity or unpaid care for those who meet certain income standards. They say they take legal action against patients only when necessary.
“Across all industries, it is a common business practice to pursue legal actions for payment of services rendered,” said Mellissa Herron, a spokeswoman for Norman Regional Health System, which has filed more than 1,400 lawsuits since Jan. 1, 2016.
But Caitlin Donovan, spokeswoman for the National Patient Advocate Foundation, said hospitals, especially nonprofit ones, are suing too often and should be more aware of their moral obligation to patients.
“When you have situations of aggressive billing, you have a system designed to just discourage people from seeking care,” Donovan said.
Lawsuits Come at Rapid Clip
There’s no standard practice across the state for when hospitals sue and when they don’t.
But Oklahoma Watch’s review of court records shows just over half of the 109 hospitals that are Oklahoma Hospital Association members have sued at least one patient over unpaid medical bills since 2016.
From the Court Files: The Walmart Worker
A Rogers County Walmart worker saw her biweekly take-home pay shrink by 25%, to $526, after she was sued by Saint Francis Health System over $9,240 in bills stemming from a series of hospital visits in 2016 and 2017. The garnishment began in February and, at this pace, the total judgment with legal fees will take 31 months to pay off.
Some hospitals sue far more frequently than others. The larger hospitals or hospital systems tend to sue more often, but some smaller hospitals also go to court a lot for their size.
Saint Francis Health System, a Catholic nonprofit group with eight hospitals, including Tulsa’s 1,112-bed Saint Francis Hospital, filed the most lawsuits over the period.
The health system is Oklahoma’s second largest, with 1,373 staffed beds, or about 12 percent of the total staffed beds in the state, according to the latest data from the American Hospital Directory.
But the system’s nearly 5,000 lawsuits made up about 22% of the legal actions identified by Oklahoma Watch.
Lauren Landwerlin, who heads corporate communication for the health system, said in a statement that Saint Francis has sued less than 1% of its patients over unpaid debts since 2016.
She said that patients, uninsured or not, can receive a full discount on medically necessary services” if they have a family income at or below 225 percent of the federal poverty level.
That would cover a single person with a gross income of less than $28,104, or a family of four earning less than $57,939.
From the Court Files: Default Judgment
A Logan County Hobby Lobby employee was sued in 2017 over $5,216 in debts owed to Integris Deaconess Hospital, which was then run by AllianceHealth. After a default judgment in favor of the hospital, between $600 and $680 per pay period was garnished from his biweekly wages until the debt was paid.
Landwerlin said Saint Francis offers payment plans “tailored to a patient’s individual circumstance” if they don’t meet the income standards.
“The system only seeks legal intervention when all other attempts to work on a solution with the patient have been exhausted,” she said. “We work with patients early in the process to set up a payment plan that meets their individual needs.”
Court filings show the hospital system filed 27 lawsuits a week on average. And in at least a half-dozen cases, Saint Francis sued and garnished wages from its own employees.
As with several other hospitals, in almost every case it pursued, Saint Francis used the debt collection law firm Works and Lentz, which has offices in Oklahoma City and Tulsa.
The federal Consumer Financial Protection Bureau ruled in 2017 that the firm, which mainly collects medical debt for Oklahoma health providers, engaged in illegal collection practices and ordered that it pay $577,135 in relief to consumers and a $78,800 penalty. According to a consent order, the firm attempted collections on about 700,000 debts totaling more than $500 million annually.
From the Court Files: The Schoolteacher
A Norman Public Schools teacher and her husband were sued by Norman Regional Hospital in November 2016 seeking $3,375 in medical bills. The couple settled with the hospital to pay $200 per month until the bill and more than $560 in court fees were paid.
Integris Health Care System, the largest health provider in the state with 16 hospitals and more than 1,700 patient beds, filed at least 4,275 lawsuits, according to the analysis of court records. Integris Deaconess, which joined the health care system last year, has filed 3,278 lawsuits since early 2016.
Integris spokeswoman Brooke Cayot said the hospital system doesn’t track the number of lawsuits because they are filed through outside collection attorneys.
But, she said, considering that the hospital system treats hundreds of thousands of patients each year, the numbers are relatively small. She said lawsuits are filed as a “final resort” and are reserved for “those who have the ability to pay and choose not to” or those who don’t provide enough information to determine whether they can pay.
She said last year Integris provided more than $34 million in charity care and reported more than $26 million in uncompensated care.
“We may be a large organization, but our heart is in the right place and we truly do care for the people of Oklahoma and the communities we serve,” she said.
Integris’ financial and uncompensated-care figures from last year weren’t immediately available. The latest federal reports, from 2014, show that hospitals statewide spent an average of 2.7% of net patient revenue on charity care and had 6.5% in total uncompensated care.
Other Oklahoma hospitals or groups that have sued more frequently are AllianceHealth Midwest (1,584 lawsuits), Norman Regional Health System (1,428), AllianceHealth Woodward (1,088 lawsuits) and St. John Medical Center (1,026).
Although their number of lawsuits were similar, AllianceHealth Woodward operates 87 patient beds compared to St. John’s 772.
Which Oklahoma Hospitals Sue the MostThis table includes hospitals or hospital systems that have sued at least 50 patients since Jan. 1, 2016, according to Oklahoma Watch's analysis of court files through the Oklahoma State Court Network and the On Demand Court Records. Additional cost-report data comes from the American Hospital Directory.
|Hospital Name||City||Lawsuits||Staffed Beds||Gross Patient Revenue|
|Saint Francis Health System*||Tulsa||4,969||1373||$4,099,159,000|
|Integris Deaconess Hospital||Oklahoma City||3,278||231||$748,506,000|
|AllianceHealth Midwest||Midwest City||1,584||255||$1,298,617,000|
|Norman Regional Health System||Norman||1,428||381||$1,936,163,000|
|Integris Baptist Medical Center||Oklahoma City||1,120||600||$3,545,481,000|
|Saint John Health System||Tulsa/Broken Arrow||1,106||609||$2,478,555,000|
|Integris Canadian Valley Regional Hospital||Yukon||1,059||75||$331,284,000|
|Integris Southwest Medical Center||Oklahoma City||783||265||$1,251,256,000|
|Oklahoma State University Medical Center||Tulsa||604||171||$458,094,000|
|Integris Bass Baptist Health Center||Enid||538||183||$416,635,000|
|Integris Health Edmond||Edmond||319||40||$330,501,000|
|Purcell Municipal Hospital||Purcell||274||39||$23,574,000|
|Hillcrest Hospital South||Tulsa||265||164||$816,152,000|
|Grady Memorial Hospital||Chickasha||175||49||$93,615,000|
|Hillcrest Hospital Claremore||Claremore||157||65||$294,700,000|
|Bailey Medical Center||Owasso||155||73||$232,913,000|
|Oklahoma University Medical Center||Oklahoma City||130||716||$6,130,508,000|
|Comanche County Memorial Hospital||Lawton||129||249||$911,745,000|
|Hillcrest Hospital Cushing||Cushing||116||95||$78,326,000|
|One Core Health Orthopedic Hospital||Oklahoma City||100||8||$84,733,000|
|AllianceHealth Ponca City||Ponca City||67||47||$281,780,000|
|Lakeside Women's Hospital||Oklahoma City||52||23||$114,575,000|
|Wagoner Community Hospital||Wagoner||51||100||$51,419,000|
Patients at Disadvantage in Court
Oklahoma City attorney Gregg Luther counts medical debt among his law firm’s specialties.
He said it’s rare for patients being sued by a hospital to retain an attorney unless it’s pro bono, or free. Few people in these situations can afford a lawyer or know what steps to take.
As a result, “the hospitals know they are going to get a default (judgment) and start garnishing wages in every case,” Luther said.
This puts patients at a disadvantage, he said, because medical bills often have errors that overcharge patients hundreds or thousands of dollars and, if asked, hospitals will often work with people to pay off their debts. He added hospital administrators have a social responsibility to not throw patients into a financial crisis over amounts that will barely affect a hospital’s bottom line.
“These are nonprofit hospitals too, many of them with crosses on their top,” he said. “Jesus didn’t say you should sue the poor. Come on man, it is just wrong on every level.”
From the Court Files: Objection in Handwriting
A Sand Springs couple was sued last year by Saint Francis Health System, which sought to collect $2,879 from four hospital visits between 2016 and 2017. In a handwritten response, the couple disputed the charges, saying that their insurance should have covered it. A judge ruled in favor of Saint Francis and ordered that the couple pay $1,000 in legal fees on top of their bill. An accompanying affidavit showed the attorney spent 12 hours on the case.
Court records show more often than not, hospitals were awarded default judgments because the patient didn’t show up for a court hearing or didn’t respond to the complaint.
If the hospital’s attorney can verify the patient’s employment status, garnishments can begin a few months after a judge rules. Federal law allows creditors to claim up to 25% of an employee’s disposable income.
Elk City resident Shameron Ahiers contested her charges.
She was sued by AllianceHealth Clinton in December 2017, which sought to collect on a nearly $14,325 bill plus $3,580 in attorney fees, stemming from a shoulder surgery to her then 13-year-old son in 2016.
“I sent them all the paperwork they needed filled out,” she said. “The next thing you know I’m being sued for the whole amount of a surgery that was pre-authorized by two insurers.”
Ahiers said she couldn’t afford a lawyer, but she filed a court response disputing the charges. She was unable to sway the judge, who in April ruled for the hospital.
Ahiers, who worked for the Oklahoma State Department of Health until 2017 and has had a series of jobs since, has yet to see her wages garnished.
She isn’t sure what steps to take next, but said she can’t afford to sit by and wait for garnishment.
“It would financially devastate me,” she said.