Two weeks into his stay in Lexington A&R, a guard approached Robert Lavern’s cell door and told him to gather his belongings.
Lavern was accustomed to moving. Over the course of four weeks, he relocated from his Talala home to the Rogers County Jail to Lexington Assessment and Reception Center, where newly sentenced male inmates are classified by security level and gang affiliation and then shipped off to prisons across the state.
This time there was no bus outside waiting for Lavern. It was mid-March, when Oklahoma schools were canceling in-person classes, restaurants were closing their dining areas and sports arenas and movie theaters went dark.
As the state corrections department suspended visitation and mandated temperature checks for staff, Lexington staff was bracing for the pandemic.
“They had me in unit eight or nine,” Lavern recalls, “and they decided they were going to turn that unit into a quarantine unit.”
A guard led Lavern, a 51-year-old Talala man serving a six-month sentence for a felony drug offense, to the prison’s basement and locked him in a solitary cell.
Lavern remembers days spent in solitary confinement, reading through Psalms and Revelation, praying for his mother and children back home in northeast Oklahoma. As he sat alone in the dark cell, Lexington staff approached Lavern and informed him that he would be transferred to William S. Key Correctional Center, a minimum-security prison in the far northwest Oklahoma town of Fort Supply.
Built in 1989 adjacent to the Fort Supply Historic Site, William S. Key houses mostly nonviolent drug and property offenders. Inmates take part in drug treatment, education and job training programs. The facility didn’t have a fence until 2016.
Lavern knew William S. Key would be an obvious upgrade from the solitary cell under normal circumstances. But the drawbacks of the facility are more pronounced during a pandemic
Inmates live in open, dormitory-style housing areas, where several dozen steel bunk beds are spaced three or four feet apart. They share bathrooms and a single dayroom area. Coronavirus restrictions meant less opportunities to go outside and take job training and education classes.
By late September, 82% of inmates housed there had tested positive for COVID-19. Robert Lavern was one of them.
As the Department of Corrections bus turned off the two-lane rural highway into William S. Key, Lavern says he had one thing on his mind: Surviving the next six months and getting back home.
Home for Lavern is Talala, a rural community 37 miles north of downtown Tulsa.
He grew up running tractors and milking cows on a farm north of town. After high school he got married, started working as a truck driver and eventually saved enough money to buy a plot of land near the Oologah Lake. He and his wife built a house and raised three children there.
He attended the Talala Christian Church and served as a volunteer reserve officer with the local police department. His weekends were spent catching crappies and gathering for fish frys with friends and family.
Lavern and his wife divorced in 2010. Two years later, Lavern said one of his fishing buddies convinced him to try meth. They started using the drug and manufacturing it in Lavern’s home.
Rogers County sheriff’s deputies were tipped off about meth production at the home and sent an undercover officer to buy drugs. In June 2014, Lavern was arrested and charged with possession of a controlled substance with intent to distribute. He pleaded guilty and received a 10-year deferred sentence, giving him a chance at avoiding prison.
He didn’t. Rogers County prosecutors asked a judge to impose a harsher sentence after Lavern’s August 2018 arrest for driving under the influence.
The judge sided with prosecutors during a Feb. 18 hearing, ordering Lavern to complete a six-month drug treatment program, with one stipulation. He had to complete it inside a state prison.
Lavern says the deficiencies of the housing area inside William S. Key’s A West unit became clear after a few days. Mold accumulated on the floor and ceilings, especially in the restroom and shower area. Inmates were rarely allowed outside, and some prisoners used the abundance of free time inside to pursue hustles like drug dealing and gambling, Lavern said.
A greater concern than the gangs and drug dealers, he says, was a lack of social distancing and mask compliance inside A West.
On April 4, all state facilities received shipments of cloth masks that were distributed to inmates. A day later, the agency ordered its facilities to keep inmates inside their cells as much as possible. Staff and guards were instructed to wear masks at all times.
Lavern says several William S. Key guards didn’t take these orders seriously.
“‘It was ‘make sure you wear the mask in front of the camera,’ ” he said. “Or you’d have one guard scream at you to wear a mask, and the next one is in the bathroom smoking a cigarette with two or three inmates without a mask.”
By the end of April, confirmed COVID-19 cases had been reported in all but seven counties in the state. By mid-May, Guymon, a city 109 miles west of William S. Key and home to the Seaboard Farms pork processing plant, had the nation’s highest coronavirus infection rate.
As Texas and Kansas coped with raging prison outbreaks, confirmed COVID-19 cases in Oklahoma’s corrections system remained low through the middle of the summer. There were only 16 confirmed cases among staff and inmates as of July 15.
On that day, facing a $24 million budget shortfall, the Department of Corrections made a decision that would trigger mass inmate movement. The board voted to close the Cimarron Correctional Facility in Cushing, a private prison which housed 1,650 prisoners. All Cimarron inmates were transferred to other facilities by Sept. 1.
The board also decided to close the Kate Barnard Correctional Center, a minimum-security women’s prison in Oklahoma City, and transition the Northeast Oklahoma Correctional Center in Vinita from a minimum-security men’s prison to a work camp.
From mid-July through early September, corrections officials report that 4,518 inmates—making up one in five Oklahoma prisoners—were transferred to another facility.
Many of these inmates were not tested for COVID-19 before being moved.
“We’ve been working with the Department of Health this whole time, and depending on the moves and situations at each facility, those decisions [on testing inmates] have been made,” Wolf said in September.
Lavern says dozens of inmates from Cimarron arrived at William S. Key in July and August, crowding the open dormitory in A West and making it more difficult to social distance. He claims staff at the facility also put inmates in compromising positions.
“There was no separation whatsoever,” he said. “There never was the whole time I was in there. They’d scream and yell at you to wear a mask, but then they’d stick you in the lunchroom with a couple hundred people at a time. They’d line people up the whole length of the whole building to get their new masks.”
He recalls guards, with their mask hanging underneath their nose and mouth, bragging about large Fourth of July gatherings. In mid-August there was a tornado drill where hundreds of inmates crammed into a basement office area. Lavern says some wore masks, others didn’t.
By then COVID-19 hotspots were flaring in state prisons. On July 22, corrections officials reported 87 active cases at the Lexington Assessment and Reception Center. Four weeks later, the Department of Corrections reported 100 positive cases at the Mabel Bassett Correctional Center, a women’s prison in McLoud. Nearly every woman housed at the Eddie Warrior Correctional Facility, a minimum-security women’s prison in Taft, tested positive for COVID-19 in late August.
As the virus spread to more prisons and social distancing remained next to impossible, Lavern said William S. Key inmates were bracing for an outbreak.
“Everybody was talking about it,” he said. “It wasn’t ‘are we going to get it’, it was ‘when?’ ”
The “when” was late August, when inmates in A Unit started coming down with common coronavirus symptoms like a cough and fever.
The inmates who informed staff of their symptoms were moved from A West to the solitary housing unit, normally reserved for inmates facing disciplinary action for fighting or disrespecting.
There’s no air conditioning, bed frame or television inside the solitary cells where inmates are locked down up to 23 hours per day, Lavern said. He claims the fear of isolation and being forgotten kept many from disclosing their symptoms.
“Lots of people would rather take a chance at dying than be sent in there,” Lavern said.
While the state Department of Corrections can mandate mask wearing and health screenings, individual facilities must decide where to quarantine sick inmates, Wolf said. It typically depends on where they have the most space available. For example, staff at Eddie Warrior moved several sick inmates into a gymnasium away from the general population when faced with an outbreak in late August.
Wolf said he could understand why some William S. Key inmates were deterred from informing staff of their symptoms and going into solitary confinement, but ultimately that action was necessary to try and contain the virus.
“Unfortunately, we have to do what’s in the best interest of all inmates, that always comes first,” he said. “So that involves tough decisions.”
Lavern says William S. Key inmates experiencing coronavirus symptoms faced another tough decision. Disclosing their symptoms and asking for help risked upsetting gang members.
“Wherever their bunk is, that’s their house and that’s where their stuff is,” Lavern said. “So they don’t want guards or a lot of attention. So if you’re sick, you’d have two or three guys walking up there and telling you ‘lay there and suffer with it, because we don’t want the attention.’ ”
Sometime around Sept. 1, Lavern went to sleep with a slight cough. He woke up with a piercing headache, extreme nausea and overwhelming fatigue. He could barely muster the energy to get out of bed and use the restroom.
Though he suffers from chronic obstructive pulmonary disease, Lavern says it wasn’t worth it to ask prison staff for special medical attention. He opted to suffer as severe symptoms persisted for two weeks. His only relief came from Tylenol supplied by an acquaintance.
“It was hell,” he said. “Whatever you think how bad it could be, it was probably 10 times worse. You hear people wheezing and coughing and wondering ‘are they going to make it through the night’. Some people would be bundled up for two or three days at a time, and people would walk by and see them move a little bit to make sure they’re still breathing.”
On Sept. 17, the day Lavern says his most severe symptoms had subsided, the Woodward County Health Department arrived at the prison and conducted mass testing. His test came back positive a day later.
The testing revealed the full scope of the outbreak. As of Sept. 27, 897 of 1,087 inmates at the facility had tested positive for the coronavirus, according to Department of Corrections data. Two of the inmates died.
“There was a guy right there in my building who went to sleep feeling real bad,” Lavern said. “They gave him an inhaler, told him to use that and they’d check on him the next day. Well, the next day he’s dead.”
On Sept. 22, four days after Lavern tested positive, Gov. Kevin Stitt and Corrections Director Scott Crow held a press conference in Oklahoma City addressing the spike of coronavirus cases in prisons and announcing new mitigation efforts.
Crow told reporters that corrections staff at all facilities would be required to undergo mandatory testing at least once per month, and the agency would increase surveillance testing of inmates with pre-existing conditions. Eight days later on Sept. 30, the corrections department indefinitely suspended inmate family visitation.
As of Nov. 17, 5,404 state inmates and 520 corrections staff had tested positive for COVID-19. Of these cases, 603 among inmates and 115 among staff are active. Thirty inmates have died from COVID-19.
Outbreaks of more than 100 active cases are ongoing at Jess Dunn Correctional Center in McAlester and John H. Lilley Correctional Center in Boley. Going into the winter, Wolf said the corrections department is continuing to monitor its coronavirus response and will make changes if necessary.
“We’re doing everything we can, but what does everything we can look like?” Wolf said.
After completing the required drug treatment course, Lavern was released from William S. Key on Oct. 13.
He spends his days at home caring for his 86-year-old mother. His joints ache constantly and his sense of taste and smell have not returned. He says he’s too weak to clean leaves out of the gutter or chop firewood. His memory is fading.
“Used to I was busy constantly, and I enjoyed that,” he said. “I could be working, cutting firewood, driving a truck for somebody, being a mechanic and turning ranches. … Now, I’m perfectly content sitting here with my mom.”
Lavern says crowds of people and open spaces now give him great anxiety. Flashbacks haunt him at random points throughout the day.
Unpaid bills and his court costs keep him up at night. He owes Rogers County thousands of dollars for the three weeks he spent inside the jail in late February and early March, and also must pay $40 a month in probation fees.
He worries about the health of his mother, who returned home from an assisted living facility after he was released from prison. He wonders if he’ll ever feel well enough to get back into truck driving, and if his probation officer will add additional restrictions to his life.
“It’s all worry and it’s all stress,” Lavern said. “I got to come up with money for these fines and money for them fines. I have to make sure I have a driver or a vehicle to meet (the probation officer) whenever she wants to see me. It may not seem like much, but when you pile it on top of taking care of things at home and trying to pay other bills, it adds up.”
Like he did in the basement cell at Lexington and the bottom bunk at William S. Key, Lavern continues to lean on his faith while navigating uncertain times.
“What gives me more peace than anything is picking up the Bible,” he said. “In prison, the first thing I would do is pray for understanding. It helped. It gave me more comfort than anything.”
Keaton Ross is a Report for America corps member who covers prison conditions and criminal justice issues for Oklahoma Watch. Contact him at (405) 831-9753 or Kross@Oklahomawatch.org. Follow him on Twitter at @_KeatonRoss
Whitney Bryen contributed to this story. She is an investigative reporter and visual storyteller at Oklahoma Watch with an emphasis on domestic violence, mental health and nursing homes affected by COVID-19. Contact her at (405) 201-6057 or email@example.com. Follow her on Twitter @SoonerReporter.
MORE FROM KEATON ROSS
Long Story Short: Explaining Oklahoma’s Testing Data, Plan To Improve Prison Safety and Alarming Domestic Violence Data
On Episode 6 of Oklahoma Watch’s new podcast, three journalists share findings and insights from their recent stories.
Also, Paul Monies shares the latest on COVID-19 in Oklahoma.