September 17, 2014

Unspoken: Political Ties of Expert Witness at Executions Hearing

Print More
East Central University professor Michael Copeland speaks to members of the Oklahoma House Judiciary Committee Tuesday.

M. Scott Carter/Oklahoma Watch

East Central University professor Michael Copeland speaks to members of the Oklahoma House Judiciary Committee Tuesday.

CAPITOL WATCH

State Capitol Photo 1

M. Scott Carter

M. Scott Carter

M. Scott Carter reports on politics, legislation and other issues from the State Capitol.

 

 

 


State Rep. Mike Christian told a House committee Tuesday that he favors dropping lethal injection and instead using an inert gas, such as nitrogen or helium, to execute condemned prisoners.

To examine the method, Christian said he turned to the criminal justice department at East Central University in Ada. Thus, at the hearing, Michael Copeland, an ECU criminal justice professor and attorney, told lawmakers that he had reviewed research on the potential of nitrogen or helium to cause death by hypoxia and found that either gas was a humane and effective method of executing prisoners.

What Copeland and Christian did not tell the House Judiciary Committee was that Copeland was involved in Christian’s 2010 campaign for the state House.

East Central University professor Michael Copeland speaks to members of the Oklahoma House Judiciary Committee Tuesday.

M. Scott Carter / Oklahoma Watch

East Central University professor Michael Copeland speaks to members of the Oklahoma House Judiciary Committee Tuesday.

During the 2013 bribery trial of state Rep. Randy Terrill, Copeland told an Oklahoma County jury that he came to Oklahoma City in 2010 to help his friend, Christian, run for political office. Copeland was testifying on behalf of the defense. Christian was also a witness at Terrill’s trial.

Before to coming to Oklahoma, Copeland said he served as assistant attorney general for the Republic of Palau, a small island in the western Pacific Ocean.

On Tuesday, Christian told lawmakers that the state must move beyond the era of lethal injections to carry out the death penalty.

“After visiting with my friends down at East Central and spending hours on research, discussing this problem, we think we’ve found a solution,” he said. “The solution we’ve come up with is nitrogen hypoxia.” He said he plans to introduce legislation allowing nitrogen or helium to be used in executions.

Lawmakers seemed interested in Christian’s proposal, but raised questions about  Copeland’s study. State Rep. Emily Virgin, D-Norman, asked Copeland why no physicians participated in the study.

“I can’t help but notice that none of the people on this list are medical professionals,” she said.

Copeland said he had contacted officials with the University of Oklahoma’s Health Sciences Center who initially agreed to participate in the study, then later declined.

M. Scott Carter can be reached at scarter@oklahomawatch.org.

  • Alan Zure

    There are numerous clinical studies demonstratin the effect of nitrogen hypoxia. The Dutch military even regularly tests this effect on their air force pilots, though only to the point of unconsciousness, not death. Michael Portillo, a former member of British parliament and BBC contributor was filmed taking the nitrogen hypoxia test. This footage is openly available on YouTube.

    I don’t care what Professor Copeland’s background is. He is finally advancing a concept (nitrogen execution) that was first proposed by Stuart Creque two decades ago in an article submitted to National Review. Nitrogen would be reliable, fast acting and not at all uncomfortable for a means by which one is put to death.